Faulty boots land seafood plant with reprisal order

Board finds sending worker home without pay after boot dispute was a prohibited reprisal

Faulty boots land seafood plant with reprisal order

The Nova Scotia Labour Board orders a seafood processor to compensate a worker sent home during a PPE dispute, Vice-Chair Raffi Balmanoukian rules on November 5, 2026.   

One hole, two bad replacements, and an early exit   

In Coiffi v. Clearwater Seafoods Highland Fisheries, 2026 NSLB 150, the board partially allowed a reprisal appeal under Section 45 of the Nova Scotia Occupational Health and Safety Act. The employee, a sanitation lead hand of approximately ten years with the company, filed a reprisal complaint after being sent home during his March 6, 2026 evening shift. He had refused to work in replacement boots he considered unsafe and sought over $20,000 in lost wages.   

The employee discovered a hole in his work boot at the start of his 6:00 pm shift. At 7:55 pm, he was provided a replacement pair of size elevens, which he found too large. A second pair of a different brand was offered at 8:05 pm, but these were uninsulated. He refused to continue working and was sent home at 8:12 pm, paid only until 9:00 pm.   

The Director of Occupational Health and Safety had found no evidence of a reprisal action in a May 21, 2026 decision. On appeal, the board disagreed on the March 6 events, finding the employee’s removal from his shift was a reprisal in relation to compliance with or enforcement of the act.   

Early March in Nova Scotia without insulated boots   

The employer argued insulated boots were only required when the plant was processing clams, which it was not at the time. The board was not persuaded, noting there was “no evidence of whether insulated boots were appropriate, as opposed to required, in the circumstances” and that it “was an evening shift in early March in Nova Scotia.”   

Applying the three-part test from Wooten v. 323195 Nova Scotia Limited, 2014 NSLB 72, the board found the employer failed to establish its decision to send the employee home was motivated solely by legitimate business reasons. There was nothing to satisfy the board that the employer’s inability to supply proper PPE justified removing the employee from his shift without substitutional work or full shift pay.  

The employee also alleged his hours had been reduced as retaliation. The board reviewed timesheets from 2023 through 2025, which showed hours of 1,390.75 in 2023, 1,425 in 2024, and 1,513 in 2025. The board found there was “nothing to show such a material deviation in early 2026 to conclude that the scheduling constituted a reprisal or threat of reprisal.”   

Difficult employee, undeniable right to safe gear   

The employee alleged a March 9 training session was used as a pretext to change his status to return-to-work, and that his medical information was discussed in front of co-workers. The employer and several employees described the session differently, with co-worker statements describing the employee as “agitated” and “disruptive.” The employee also alleged a disciplinary letter from that date was fabricated.   

The board found the return-to-work status was not a prohibited reprisal. Even if it were, the board held the employer was “motivated solely by legitimate business reasons — a harmonious and respectful workplace.” The employee’s separate union grievance and complaint before the Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission remain active and were expressly left to their respective forums. 

The employer was ordered to pay the employee the balance of his March 6 shift, less deductions. All other claims were dismissed. The board acknowledged the employee was “a difficult and demanding employee” but held “that does not disconnect him from his right to safe and reasonably appropriate gear.” 

RELATED STORIES